[Samba] Best Way to install a Samba4 DC with Samba3 Memberserver

[Hauke Homburg]

Am 23.05.2014 14:10, schrieb Marc Muehlfeld:
> Hello Hauke,
>
> Am 23.05.2014 13:09, schrieb Hauke Homburg:
>> Ich want wo install a SAMBA4 DC with an SAMBA 3 Memberserver.
>>
>> Ich want to install the Linux with Debian Whezzy and the SAMBA 4
>> Packages from Sernet.
>>
>> I think i have the Choice to install the SAMBA 3 Server with the Debian
>> Packages oder with the Sernet Packages. What is the best Way to do this?
> What exactly do you mean? How to install the packages? Or configure the
> Member Server in general?
>
>
> Why do you want to install the Member Server with the old version 3x?
> Samba 4.1 is maintained and contains many improvements.
>
> Samba 3.6 will be discontinued soon (when 4.2 will be released). At
> least then you have to move to 4x or you have a vendor that continues to
> provide you bug and security fixes.
>
> Regards,
> Marc
Hello Marc,

Thanks for your Answer.

I thought it is better to in install a Memberserver like a Fileserver 
with SAMBA 3 because i wasn't sure to use a SAMBA 4 Installation for 
Fileservices, too.
My actual Knowlede is that SAMBA 4 is primally for the AD Services. The 
File Service is in the SAMBA 3 Code in Package.
I didn't know that SAMBA should be discontinued with SAMBA 4.2.

So i think it is the best Way to install both, DC and Memberserver, with 
SAMBA 4?

What is the State of the Nested Group Support in the File Services of 
SAMBA 4? I want to use AGDLP for Rightsmanagement.
Till this day ich installed the "old" SAMBA 4 iso Image from Sernet and 
the UCS Server 3.0. In the face off it the nested group support was not 
good.

greetings

Hauke