Samba 4.12 rc3: bind DNS say "named: client update denied"

Dario Lesca d.lesca at
Sat Mar 14 16:45:50 UTC 2020

Il giorno sab, 14/03/2020 alle 15.45 +0000, Rowland penny via samba-
technical ha scritto:
> Both ;-), the record should be added when you join a Samba DC, 
What you means exactly with "when you join a Samba DC"?
"join a PC to a Samba DC" or "join a Samba DC to a ..."?
I think the first is right

> Ahh, a Windows DC will not have samba_dnsupdate, 
Yes, it not have. But here I do not use a Windows DC, it's a Samba DC.
The Windows are the client.
Why you say "a Windows DC" ? what does it mean?

> you will probably have 
> to create the records manually with samba-tool or ADUC
Yes I have do that initially.
But now the record it's gone, I have remove it and I have un-join and
re-join the win10a pc and join the new win10b

> You are using the Fedora packages to provision a DC, 
Yes I use the Fedora packages for test it. 

> it looks like you might just have found another reason not use them
> for a DC ;-)
No eventually, if so, I have found another reason to fill a bug on
RedHat Bugzilla.

Since you tell me it should do it, this is a bug

> > Many thanks for you patient.
> Couple of answers to that ;-)
> Either: 'yes doctor'
> Or: I think you mean 'patience'

Yes, I mean "patience", a lot of patience for my bad English !


Dario Lesca
(inviato dal mio Linux Fedora 31 Workstation)

More information about the samba-technical mailing list