s3 to join s4

Collen cblijenberg at hermanjordan.nl
Thu Dec 8 04:41:22 MST 2011

Ok, no sorry.

I've tested it today and still have the problems..

i can join the s4 domain, but still get the dns invalid error
the s3 shows up in the computer list on the AD, but not in the DNS

i can browse to S3 with windows, resolving usernames and group names fails.

on the S3 net ads group/user/info all works nice (i can see the users 
and groups)

wbinfo fails in allways

getent makes the winbind coredump ?! (on s3)
something with talloc magic value unkown.

s3 version 3.6.1 - s4 git pull from yesterday

so it's not really working for me.

greetz, Collen

On 5-12-2011 17:38, Matthieu Patou wrote:
> On 05/12/2011 16:40, Collen wrote:
>> Hi, just a quick question,
>> what s3 version is better to use to join s4 ?
>> 3.5 or 3.6 ? (both on different machines)
> Both should work.
>> i did try 3.6 but get a dns_update error after the net ads join.
>> (dns_invallid_message)
> That's a long lasting bug, it should have been fixed lately and should
> be in the 4.0 (or 3.7 depending on which came first).
>> the join was successful, but is not working (?)
> What make you think so ?
> Matthieu.

Collen Blijenberg - systeem/netwerk beheerder

More information about the samba-technical mailing list