Rename deadlock possible with Samba and ZFS On Linux in case insensitive mode
realrichardsharpe at gmail.com
Wed Dec 23 20:56:45 UTC 2015
We have just run into a problem with Samba and ZFS On Linux so I
thought I would let people know what the issue is.
We run ZFS On Linux in case-insensitive mode. During an FSCT test we
started seeing deadlocks. We tracked the deadlocks down to renames and
lock_rename in the Linux kernel deadlocking while trying to take the
node-specific i_mutex twice.
This happened because two path names were used in the rename,
Internally we had a path like a/some-path/SomeOtherPath/SomeFile.xyz
for the source of the rename and windows gave us
A/some-path/SomeOtherPath/SomeOtherFile.xyz for the destination of the
The only difference was the case of the first component.
Since ZFS On Linux currently does not call d_add_ci in zpl_lookup when
the file system is Case Insensitive it results in two dentries in the
file pointing to the same inode and will cause deadlocks on rename.
A bug has been filed against the ZoL github repository:
You can work around it to some extent in Samba but a full solution
will be a problem and there appears to be a simple solution in ZFS On
More information about the samba-technical