John H Terpstra
jht at samba.org
Wed Aug 31 21:56:26 MDT 2011
Pardon top-posting - I am replying purely to place on record the
following link to info regarding debugging EPM issues in MS Windows. I
suspect you already know about this KB article, but just FYI here it is:
- John T.
On 08/31/2011 10:25 PM, tridge at samba.org wrote:
> Hi Andreas,
> > The implementation of the Endpoint Mapper is complete. All functions needed by
> > Windows clients are supported and fully implemented. In addition we support
> > epm_Insert and epm_Delete over ncalrpc to be able to register and remove
> > endpoints as the system user.
> have you been able to confirm that the epm_Insert and epm_Delete
> functions are wire compatible with Windows clients/servers? I tried
> running the rpc.epmapper test against Windows and it fails with a RPC
> fault, which may indicate that the wire format is not correct. Note
> that our epmapper.idl doesn't use the same IDL form as the IDL in the
> OpenGroup spec, so its quite plausible that we are not wire
> > The epmd can detect if a rpc service dies cause of the open connection. If the
> > service dies and the connection is closed we delete the registered endpoints
> > of the service form the database.
> this is certainly a good idea
> > The goal should be to use the epmd implementation of Samba3 in the future. The
> > Samba4 epmapper implementation is pretty simple and tied to S4. There is no
> > easy way to register new endpoints from external.
> I'm not convinced that adopting epmd as the normal approach for the
> Samba 4.0 release is the right way to go. The 'tied to s4' argument
> seems weak given we don't have any plans for another 3.x release.
> What about extracting the work you have done into a library, and then
> using that library in both the source4/rpc_server/epmapper/ service
> and the epmd service?
> We certainly can't just drop the current source4/ epmapper, as that
> would make all of the current source4 RPC services unavailable. I also
> don't want to lose the ability to run the source4/ rpc services in
> single mode, using the task abstraction.
> > The epm_Map and epm_Lookup function are incomplete.
> can you tell me what calls made by Windows clients fail against the
> current source4/ epmapper? I know it doesn't allow for the
> registration of new services, which you need for IPA, but I am curious
> as to whether you have also found ways in which Windows clients
> interact with us that fail with the current code.
> Cheers, Tridge
More information about the samba-technical