Large numbers of files in a directory - take #2 :-)
jra at samba.org
Thu Feb 3 19:22:27 GMT 2005
Ok, second attempt now I'm sure the code is working :-).
JohnT - if you want to turn this into a HOWTO or part of
the book, be my guest. Remember it'll be in 3.0.12, not
3.0.11 or below.
I've been working (inspired by James Peach of SGI) on the
problem of using Samba3 with applications that need large
numbers of files (100,000 or more) per directory.
I think the current code in SVN in the SAMBA_3_0 branch
may hold the fix for this problem, so I'd like to request
people who need this functionality to give it a try.
The key was fixing the directory handling to read only
the current list requested instead of the old (up to 3.0.11)
behaviour of reading the entire directory into memory before
doling out names. Normally this would have broken OS/2
applications which have *very* strange delete semantics :-),
but by stealing logic from Samba4 (thanks tridge) I think
the current code in SVN handles this correctly.
So here's how to set up an application that needs large
number of files per directory in a way that doesn't damage
Firstly, you need to canonicalize all the files in the
directory to have one case, upper or lower - take your
pick (I chose upper as all my files were already upper
case names). Then set up a new custom share for the
application as follows:
path = /home/jeremy/tmp/manyfilesdir
read only = no
case sensitive = True
default case = upper
preserve case = no
short preserve case = no
Of course, use your own path and settings, but set the
case options to match the case of all the files in your
directory. The path should point at the large directory
needed for the application - any new files created in
there and in any paths under it will be forced by smbd
into upper case - but smbd will no longer have to scan
the directory for names - it knows that if a file doesn't
exist in upper case then it doesn't exist at all.
The secret to this is really in the "case sensitive = True"
line - it tells smbd never to scan for case-insensitive
versions of names. So if an application asks for a file
called "FOO", and it can't be found by a simple stat call,
then smbd will return file not found immediately without
scanning the containing directory for a version of a different
case. The other "xxx case xxx" lines make this work by forcing
a consistent case on all files created by smbd.
Remember, all files and directories under the "path" directory
must be in upper case with this smb.conf stanza as smbd won't
be able to find lower case filenames with these settings. Also
note this is done on a per-share basis, allowing this to be set
only for a share servicing an application with this problematic
behaviour (using large numbers of entries in a directory) - the
rest of your smbd shares don't need to be affected.
This makes smbd *much* faster when dealing with large directories.
My test case has over 100,000 files and smbd now deals with this
So please give this a test if you have problems with
Samba and large sized directories. Remember this is in SVN code
only, it isn't in the 3.0.11 pre releases or rc candidates,
as we need to ensure this new code is correct. If you
can help me test it it'll be in 3.0.12 (security problems
More information about the samba-technical