IPv4/v6 socket problem on BSD
naddy at mips.inka.de
Sun Jul 28 11:33:02 EST 2002
Currently, if IPv6-enabled rsync is run as --daemon, it will perform
a wildcard bind(2) on an AF_INET6 socket and expect that IPv4 traffic
will be forwarded to the v6 socket (IPv4 mapped address, RFC2553).
This has never worked on OpenBSD which disallows IPv4 mapped addresses
for security reasons. On FreeBSD 5.0-CURRENT, where the behavior
is subject to configuration, the default was switched to "disable"
a few days ago. According to their man page, NetBSD share this.
Server processes that are to deal with IPv4 and IPv6 traffic will
have to bind to two sockets, one for each protocol family. Servers
that fail to do so and rely on the old IPv4 mapped addresses will
end up handling IPv6 only.
Symptoms on typical IPv6-enabled but only IPv4-connected hosts are
that the daemon appears to be running fine but can't be reached.
netstat -a will show a protocol type of tcp6 instead of the expected
Workarounds for IPv4-only users include specifying an appropriate
--address or building rsync with --disable-ipv6.
Currently, rsync in daemon mode is only designed to read from a single
socket. Extending this to two sockets will require a bit of reworking,
e.g. introducing a select(2) loop. This also suggests extending
--address to accept multiple addresses (or allow multiple --address
arguments). Altogether that's a bit more than I feel confident to
Christian "naddy" Weisgerber naddy at mips.inka.de
More information about the rsync